Conservative Pews & Liberal Pulpits (Ep 809, November 28, 2025)

Alan Smith and Jeff Rowland

Many Christians feel a strange tension on Sunday mornings. They sit in congregations where most people hold clear, conservative views on life, marriage, and truth, yet the sermon sounds soft, vague, or even friendly to ideas that clash with Scripture. That tension is the heartbeat of Conservative Pews & Liberal Pulpits.

Ep 809, aired November 28, 2025, from The Smith and Rowland Show, speaks to believers who care about faithfulness, doctrine, and public life. It looks at why the people in the seats often sound more biblically conservative than the pastors in the pulpits, and what that gap means for the future of the church.

This post is for thoughtful Christians who do not want to rage online, but who do want to think clearly, test every teaching by the Bible, and respond with both courage and grace in confusing times.

What “Conservative Pews & Liberal Pulpits” Is Really About

At its core, Conservative Pews & Liberal Pulpits names a growing divide. Many members still hold historic Christian beliefs, yet many pastors speak in a more progressive way about culture, politics, and moral issues.

In late 2025, that gap feels sharp. Western nations sit in constant culture wars over abortion, same-sex marriage, gender identity, and religious freedom. Election cycles keep everything hot. In many churches, members hold to long-standing Christian teaching while the pulpit grows quiet or even friendly toward ideas that used to be clearly rejected.

Here, "conservative" mainly means loyal to historic Christian doctrine. It means a high view of the Bible, a clear view of sin, and confidence that God has spoken with real authority. "Liberal" in this context means soft on that authority or ready to adopt ideas that do not fit Scripture, even if they sound kind or modern.

Defining Conservative Pews and Liberal Pulpits in Plain Language

Conservative pews usually look like this:

Pro-life convictions about the unborn and the elderly.
Belief in marriage as one man and one woman for life.
Strong trust in the whole Bible as God’s true Word.
Deep concern over moral decline in media, schools, and law.

Liberal pulpits often look different:

Open support for same-sex marriage or at least a refusal to say it is sin.
Weak or rare talk about judgment, hell, or God’s wrath.
Sermons focused on feelings, personal stories, or activism, but light on clear doctrine.
Use of phrases like "your truth" instead of "God’s truth."

The point is not to chase labels or team colors. The deeper issue is faithfulness to the Bible. A church can call itself conservative or evangelical and still drift. What matters is what is preached, week after week, when the Bible is open and the people are listening.

Why This Divide Feels Sharper in Late 2025

The last few years have squeezed churches. COVID policy fights, political tension, racial debates, and constant arguments over gender and sexuality have worn people out. Social media rewards outrage and shaming, not calm teaching.

Pastors feel pressure from several directions at once. Some fear being called hateful if they speak clearly about sin. Others fear losing members, donors, or their job. Some want to be seen as thoughtful and educated, so they repeat ideas from elite voices that do not respect Scripture.

Many believers in the pews feel that their concerns are brushed aside. They see schools pushing gender confusion on children, governments punishing biblical speech, and media mocking God. When their pastor avoids these issues or sounds more like the news than the Bible, they feel alone, even in their own church.

If that is you, you are not crazy and you are not alone.

How Pulpits Turn Liberal While Pews Stay Conservative

Most churches do not flip overnight. They drift. That drift often starts in places most members never see.

Leaders train in schools where professors question the Bible. Denominational heads urge "relevance" or "inclusion," but not repentance or holiness. Pastors read more books from secular thinkers than from faithful teachers. Over time, the pulpit starts to echo the culture rather than confront it.

The people in the seats, however, still read their Bibles, listen to solid teachers online, and talk with older believers. Their instincts stay more conservative, even as the sermons soften.

Softening Scripture: From Clear Teaching to Vague Talks

You can often trace a pattern:

Less Bible, more stories and quotes.
Less teaching on sin, more talk about self-esteem and "finding your purpose."
Less about the cross and resurrection, more about activism or therapy.

Red flags include:

Hard texts are skipped for whole series.
Verses are used like decoration, not explained in context.
Culture is used as the judge of which verses still apply.

When a pastor starts with what the world says, then filters the Bible through that lens, the pulpit is already drifting. Faithful preaching does the opposite. It starts with Scripture, then applies it sharply and kindly to every part of life.

Cultural Pressure on Pastors and Church Leaders

We should be honest about the pressure pastors face. If they speak clearly about abortion, marriage, or gender, they may face:

Online attacks and bad reviews.
Angry emails from members.
Loss of friends or invitations.
Threats to their job or housing.

Some pastors love Christ but feel torn. They want to shepherd all kinds of people, including those trapped in sin. The temptation is to stay silent on hard issues or to speak in language so soft that no one can object.

Believers should see the danger, but also the human side. That helps us respond with prayer, patience, and truth, not just anger.

When Politics Replaces Theology in the Sermon

The danger is not only on one side. Some pulpits sound like a rally for one political party. Others sound like a rally for social justice movements. In both cases, the gospel gets pushed to the side.

You can tell the focus has shifted when:

Sermons repeat talking points you heard all week on cable news.
The cross, sin, and grace are rare or tacked on at the end.
The main call is to vote, protest, or donate, not to repent and believe.

The answer is not to avoid public issues. Churches must speak clearly about life, marriage, justice, and truth. The key is to preach these from the Bible with Jesus at the center, rather than from party scripts.

What Faithful Believers Can Do When Their Pulpit Turns Liberal

Many Christians love their church, but feel a knot in their stomach each Sunday. They hear the sermon and wonder if they can raise their kids there.

You do not need to panic, but you also cannot ignore what you hear.

Start With Scripture, Not Party Lines

Open your Bible. Study key passages on:

The sanctity of life.
Marriage and sexuality.
God’s design for men and women.
The authority of Scripture.

Ask a simple question: "Is my church teaching this clearly and without shame?"

Do not build your convictions on talk shows or social feeds. Let Scripture shape your mind first. Then measure the pulpit by that standard, not by your favorite commentator.

How to Talk With Your Pastor Without Picking a Fight

Before you judge, talk.

Pray for humility and courage.
Ask for a meeting, not to trap him, but to understand.
Bring a Bible and a few clear questions.
Listen carefully and take notes.

Good questions include:

"Do you believe the Bible is fully true and without error?"
"What do you teach about marriage and gender?"
"How should our church respond when culture rejects these teachings?"

Healthy signs: the pastor opens a Bible, welcomes questions, and submits his views to Scripture. Concerning signs: he mocks "fundamentalists," dodges core questions, or treats the Bible as one voice among many.

When to Stay, When to Leave, and How to Guard Your Family

Sometimes a church is drifting but still open to correction. If leaders show humility, are willing to teach more clearly, and invite serious study, staying and helping may be wise.

Other times, the church has already crossed into false teaching. That is the case when:

Clear sins are affirmed as holy.
The gospel of grace is replaced by moralism or activism.
Leaders refuse to be corrected by Scripture.

In those cases, you must guard your home. Children and teens learn far more from weekly teaching than from one talk at the dinner table. If you need to leave, do it without gossip. Speak facts, not rumors. Keep loving those who stay, but protect your family’s diet of truth.

Building Churches Where Pews and Pulpits Stand on the Same Truth

God’s aim is not permanent war between conservative pews and liberal pulpits. The goal is healthy unity around His Word.

In a healthy church:

Pastors preach the whole counsel of God, not just safe topics.
Members love the truth even when it cuts across their preferences.
The church engages hard cultural issues without losing the gospel.

This moment in late 2025 can be a wake-up call. Instead of drifting with trends, believers can dig deeper into Scripture, strengthen local churches, and prepare the next generation to stand.

Marks of a Faithful Pulpit in a Confused Culture

Use this simple checklist when you sit under any pulpit:

Clear, regular explanation of Scripture in context.
The gospel, not self-help, as the center of every message.
Courage to name sins the culture approves.
Humility and repentance when error is shown.
Equal care for both truth and love in tone and content.

No pastor is perfect, but direction matters. A faithful pulpit keeps pointing people to Christ, not to the spirit of the age.

How Ordinary Church Members Help Keep the Pulpit Faithful

Members are not powerless. You can:

Pray by name for your pastors each week.
Thank them when they preach hard truths with grace.
Support elders who stand for sound doctrine.
Join solid Bible studies and invite others.
Refuse to cheer for shallow teaching, even if it is funny or trendy.

Acts 17 praises the Bereans who tested everything by Scripture. That same spirit, alive in ordinary members, helps keep pulpits tethered to God’s Word.

Conclusion

The gap between conservative pews and liberal pulpits is real, but God is not shaken. He has always guarded His church through seasons of confusion and compromise.

Cling to Scripture, examine your own heart, and seek churches that prize both truth and grace. Pray for your leaders, speak with them honestly, and protect what your family hears week after week. Above all, remember that your first loyalty is not to a party, tribe, or trend, but to Jesus Christ, who promised to build His church and keep it to the end.

Blogs