Why Is Your Church On The Sidelines? (Ep. 819, December 16, 2025)

Alan Smith and Jeff Rowland

A church can be busy every week and still sit on the sidelines. Programs run, sermons get preached, and calendars stay full, yet the congregation avoids the hard work of public faith, local service, and clear moral witness. The result is a church that feels safe, but also feels small.

This episode title raises a blunt question: why would a church choose the sidelines when it was called to be salt and light? If that question hits close to home, it helps to name what “sidelines” looks like, why it happens, and what moving back onto the field can look like in real life.

The Problem of Churches Sitting Out

“Sidelines” is not the same thing as “rest.” Rest is healthy. Sidelines is avoidance. It’s the posture of watching rather than acting, commenting rather than serving, and staying quiet rather than telling the truth.

Many churches don’t mean to drift there. It happens slowly. One tough issue gets skipped, one community need feels too messy, one conflict seems too risky. Over time, the congregation learns a habit: stay neutral, stay comfortable, stay unnoticed.

That habit has a cost.

A church that stays on the sidelines often loses clarity about its mission. People notice when the faith is treated like a private hobby instead of a public hope. Young believers notice. Neighbors notice. Even long-time members notice, even if they can’t name what feels “off.”

Signs Your Church Is on the Sidelines

Here are common warning signs that a church is drifting into a spectator mindset:

A silent pulpit on issues that shape everyday life (family, truth, justice, life, integrity).
A pattern of avoiding clear moral teaching to keep everyone comfortable.
Little to no local involvement when the community is hurting.
Service that stays inside the building, while needs outside go unanswered.
Fear-driven decision-making, where the main goal is “don’t upset anyone.”
A strong emphasis on attendance and giving, with weak emphasis on discipleship and obedience.

None of these mean a church is “bad.” They often mean a church is tired, uncertain, or led by people who feel boxed in. Still, the signs matter because they point to a deeper issue: hesitation to live out the faith with courage.

Why This Hurts Everyone

When a church sits out, the damage spreads wider than most people expect.

Believers stay shallow. If faith is never applied, it stays theoretical. People learn words, but not obedience.
The community loses a stabilizing presence. A healthy church often provides help, truth, and long-term care that no agency can replace.
The next generation grows skeptical. Many young people can spot performative religion. They’re drawn to conviction and action, not slogans.

A sidelined church doesn’t just lose influence. It can lose its confidence, its unity, and its ability to endure hardship.

Common Reasons Churches Stay Sidelined

Churches rarely say, “We want to be irrelevant.” The sidelines usually come from pressures that feel practical in the moment. Naming those pressures is the first step toward changing them.

Fear of Losing Tax Status (and Other Legal Worries)

One common fear is that speaking clearly about moral or civic issues will trigger legal trouble.

Church leaders hear phrases like “separation of church and state” and assume that clear teaching equals legal risk. Many also worry that any public stance could threaten a church’s standing, reputation, or finances.

A few realities help ground the discussion:

Churches have the right to teach moral truth from the pulpit.
Churches can speak about issues, values, and biblical standards without endorsing candidates.
Wisdom still matters. Careless words can create confusion, and public statements should be accurate and measured.

Fear can cause leaders to treat every sensitive topic as a legal threat. Over time, that fear trains a church to say less and less, until “safe” becomes “silent.”

How Fear Shows Up Week to Week

Fear doesn’t always sound like fear. It often sounds like spirituality.

It can sound like:

“We just want to focus on the gospel.”
“We don’t want to be political.”
“That topic is too divisive.”

Sometimes those statements are sincere. Other times, they become cover for avoiding hard truth. The gospel is not fragile. It does not need to be protected by silence.

Comfort in the Status Quo

Comfort is a powerful force in church culture because comfort feels like peace. But comfort and peace are not the same.

Common comfort traps include:

Routine over mission: Keeping the schedule becomes the goal.
Approval over truth: Avoiding complaints becomes the leadership win.
Safety over service: Ministry stays tidy, predictable, and low-cost.
Growth over depth: The church chases numbers, not maturity.
Talk over action: The church discusses needs more than it meets them.

Comfort isn’t always sinful, but it becomes dangerous when it replaces courage. A church can become so focused on keeping people happy that it stops forming people to be holy.

Lack of Bold Leadership (and Shared Responsibility)

Leadership matters, but it’s not only a pastor issue. Churches can pressure leaders into caution, then blame them for being cautious. Members can demand “keep it positive,” then complain that sermons lack substance.

Bold leadership is not loud leadership. It’s steady leadership. It teaches truth clearly, it serves publicly, and it refuses to let fear set the agenda.

At the same time, churches need more than one voice. Elders, ministry leaders, and mature members should share the load. A single leader standing alone is easier to intimidate and easier to exhaust. A church with shared courage is harder to sideline.

Biblical Reasons a Church Can’t Stay on the Bench

A church is not called to be a weekly event. It’s called to be a faithful presence.

In Scripture, God’s people are repeatedly described in active terms: witnesses, ambassadors, servants, soldiers, lights, salt. Those are not spectator roles.

What Scripture Emphasizes About Engagement

Even without naming every passage, the themes are consistent:

Truth must be spoken. Love does not require silence. Love requires honesty with humility.
Good works should be visible. Not for applause, but for the good of neighbors and the glory of God.
The vulnerable must be cared for. A church that ignores the weak is out of step with biblical priorities.
Disciples must be made. Discipleship requires instruction, correction, and practice, not just inspiration.
Courage is normal for believers. Fear is human, but living in fear is not the goal.

A church that refuses engagement will eventually redefine faith as private opinion. That shrinks the church’s calling down to personal preference, which is not what Christianity teaches.

Old Testament Patterns: Faith That Acted

In the Old Testament, faith is regularly shown through action:

People confront evil rather than accommodate it.
Leaders call communities back to covenant faithfulness.
Justice and mercy are not treated as optional add-ons.

The pattern is simple: when God’s people drift, they are called back, not to comfort, but to obedience.

New Testament Patterns: Witness With Skin On It

In the New Testament, the church grows in the middle of pressure, not in the absence of it. Believers serve, speak, sacrifice, and stay faithful even when it costs them.

A practical way to think about it is the difference between watching and witnessing:

Church posture	What it looks like	What it produces
Sidelines	Avoids conflict, stays vague, stays private	Confusion, shallow discipleship, weak witness
On the field	Teaches clearly, serves locally, speaks with courage	Maturity, credibility, community impact

The goal is not to pick fights. The goal is to stop hiding.

What It Looks Like When Churches Step Up

Active churches do not all look the same. A rural church will serve differently than a city church. A small congregation will not have the same resources as a large one.

Still, engaged churches tend to share a few traits:

They show up locally. They know the schools, the first responders, the struggling families, and the needs that never make the news.

They speak plainly. They don’t twist Scripture to match trends, and they don’t insult people who disagree. They tell the truth without acting superior.

They train people for real life. They help members apply faith at work, at home, online, and in the voting booth, without turning the church into a campaign office.

They measure fruit, not noise. They care about changed lives, restored marriages, freedom from addiction, generosity, and steady faith through suffering.

The strongest public witness is often quiet and consistent. Not every church needs a microphone. Every church needs backbone.

Steps to Get Your Church Off the Sidelines

If you’re a church member who feels the tension, the goal is not to vent. The goal is to help your church move forward in unity and conviction.

Talk to Your Pastor (With Clarity and Respect)

A productive conversation is specific, calm, and solutions-focused. Here’s a simple approach:

Share what you’re seeing in concrete terms (not accusations).
Ask what pressures the leadership is facing right now.
Offer help, not just critique.
Agree on one small next step and a time to follow up.

Helpful questions can be simple:

“What community needs are we aware of, and which ones are we addressing?”
“How are we training people to live out their faith outside Sunday?”
“Where do you feel the church hesitates most, and why?”

Build a Team of Like-Minded Members

Change rarely happens through one person pushing alone. Build a small group that prays, serves, and plans.

A healthy starting point includes:

A shared commitment to unity and truth
A clear service focus (one need, one area)
A willingness to do the work without seeking credit

Small teams can start ministries that later become church-wide efforts.

Start Small With Local Impact

A church doesn’t need a massive initiative to stop being sidelined. Momentum often begins with simple consistency.

A practical first-win checklist:

Choose one local partner (school, shelter, pregnancy center, foster network).
Commit to one monthly service effort for 90 days.
Track needs, outcomes, and volunteer load.
Share stories that highlight people served, not the church brand.
Keep the effort sustainable so it lasts.

Small wins build trust. Trust creates room for bigger steps.

Final Thoughts

A church on the sidelines often looks calm, but it’s rarely healthy. The calling of the church is public, embodied, and costly, and it’s also deeply good. When a congregation steps onto the field, people grow, neighbors get served, and faith becomes more than talk.

If the question stings, let it. Courage usually starts as discomfort. The next step is choosing faithful action over safe distance.

Blogs